hanspetermeier
Member

***
interessanter song wegen der ungewöhnlichen lyrics. kein wunder eigentlich beim Sänger der Band Fun.

TravD
Member

*****
Seems like he his trying to reconnect with his estranged mother. <br><br>Good track. The backing music and Nate Ruess' chorus is great!

orangeKILLER
Member

******
Absolut genial!
Last edited: 14.11.2013 16:03

KingBandicoot
Member

****
Fine. An interesting combination I must say. Also, Eminem must really hate his dad.<br><br>3.75*.

Miraculi
Member

****
Da hat sich Eminem das komplette Paket Nate Ruess / Jeff Bhasker und Emile Haynie eingekauft, um auch mal wieder beim Radiovolk landen zu können. Na ja, der Wüterich gibt etwas Würze - ansonsten ein sehr leichtes Liedchen.

fabio
Member

*****
cool

zaphod
Member

*****
Hab mich inzwischen ans reinplappern gewöhnt, finde die Nummer (vor allem wegen Nate Ruess) genial!
Last edited: 21.11.2013 13:09

Reto
Member

****
Der Part von Nate Ruess ist stark, aber der Hohlkopf vermasselt alles.

remember
Member

****
Sehr nett.

Zacco333
Member

****
Cool, but personally I found the chorus to be a bit odd and out of place.

timothy444
Member

******
To be honest, I was surprised that Eminem wants to talk about his mum in this song and release it as a single since I thought the topic might be a bit too controversial. But I wrong.<br><br>Anyways, I felt the emotion in the lyrics and it just feels somehow the right thing to do for Eminem to really rap about that. Nate Reuss perfectly adds to the song and it's really great for Eminem to reference Nate in his verses.<br><br>The instrumental also adds to the atmosphere. It's slow, sad and the piano takes up the majority of the beat. I'm really pleased with this track.
Last edited: 06.02.2014 12:16

Chris A
Member

*****
Good song, another good track off TMMLP2.
Last edited: 12.04.2014 09:20

KitchenTel
Member

*****
Très bonne collaboration, le refrain me transporte réellement.
Last edited: 14.08.2014 09:33

bluezombie
Member

**
The Nate chorus isn't as good as I was hoping it would be and I don't think Eminem has it in him to do anything I find appealing anymore. At least this one isn't too terrible.<br><br>Edit: Actually I heard this again the other day and it's actually really crap. The verses are shocking, Eminem sounds terrible and the lyrics are ridiculously bad. Nate can't save this.
Last edited: 04.10.2014 14:11

irelander
Member

****
The idea is nice and it works well, but Eminem is just way too shouty at times. 3.5

Snormobiel Beusichem
Member

***
▒ Géén bijzondere of opzienbarende samenwerking of plaat van het duo: "Eminem & Nate Ruess", begin november 2013 !!! Exact voldoende ☺!!!

LLonden
Member

***
Niet heel bijzonder, maar ik vind het i.e.g. geen vervelende plaat. Dat kan ik van de rest van zijn nummers op The Marshall Mathers LP2 niet zeggen!

Der_Nagel
Member

***
Sowohl Gesang als auch Rap sind für mich auf der nervigen Seite, 2.75…

alleyt1989
Member

******
Wow I really like this. A lot!
Last edited: 05.03.2014 02:38

Ghostwriter1
Member

*****
Echt nicht schlecht...würde auch ne gute Single abgeben...5-

gerry1982
Member

*****
Dit nummer van Eminem met Nate Ruess mag toch ook de Belgische hitlijsten veroveren! Leuke samenwerking!<br>

Werner
Member

****
...solide vier...

musikmannen
Member

***
Ok

tgebele
Member

******
Sehr geil!<br>

ul.tra
Member

****
Ein Starker Song für Eminem

DeejayDave
Member

****
Interessante samenwerking die ik niet zo snel had voorzien. Verder vind ik dit een vrij sterke plaat. Eminem blinkt toch altijd uit in zijn 'serieuze' platen.

Chuck_P
Member

****
schönes ding.<br><br>Edit 2022: geht klar.
Last edited: 19.03.2022 15:22

Supersok
Member

****
Kan een groeier worden. Best goed!

Sebastiaanmember
Member

***
Ik vind dit helemaal geen speciaal plaatje. Ik vind 'The Monster' dan iets beter.

Hijinx
Member

****
Thank goodness for Eminem, the only good rapper (well apart from Macklemore, Mac Miller, El-P, Vanilla Ice) and the only rapper who raps about real things, and doesn't just say ni**a over and over again. DAE Kangayfish & Lil Gayne???<br><br>But in all seriousness, this is a pretty strong cut from TMMLP2. It's interesting to see a direct callback to "Cleanin' Out My Closet", reflecting I suppose that Eminem is a less bitter man nowadays. Only thing about that is that it doesn't fit with the rest of the album since that track wasn't on TMMLP. Nate Ruess makes for a funny choice of guest vocalist too, mainly because he essentially shares his name with Eminem's brother who is mentioned in this song, which led me to briefly believing that Nate Ruess also had an estranged childhood! 3.8

LIFTER500
Member

***
Eminem's best track in years. 3.3.

Kamala
Member

****
...ohne Eminems Geplapper und Gezetter wäre es ein sehr schöner Titel - ich mag eben Nates süsse Stimme, die von Orgelklängen begleitet ist - but "I guess we are who we are"...

Hzi
Member

*****
Das mag der absurdeste Vergleich ever sein, aber: <br>Das sehr melodiöse und melancholische Backing während Eminems Parts erinnert mich an den 70er-Jahre-Teddybären-Song von diesem Pseudo-Trucker Johnny Hill ...<br><br>Ernsthaft: Ich hab auch nicht gerade das innigste Verhältnis zu meiner Mutter, darum spricht mich das Thema an. Und das Wohlfühl-Arrangement mit dem Gesangs-Refrain ist natürlich auch sehr einladend. Eigentlich überraschend, denn der Inhalt taugt wohl eher nicht fürs Radio ...
Last edited: 11.03.2016 19:39

Widmann1
Member

*****
Meine Beharrlichkeit Eminem zu hören wird belohnt, den find ich klasse.

spatz-98
Member

****
ganz okay<br><br>CDN: #87, 2013; #54, 2014<br>USA: #105, 2013; #45, 2014

gherkin
Member

***
Vind dit nu persoonlijk toch niet direct één van de allerbeste nummers van Eminem.

drogida007
Member

****
<br>Nate's Part gefällt mir sehr gut, aber Eminem verhindert eine bessere Bewertung. <br><br>2014: #66 UK

clublover
Member

******
Top

Thakob
Member

****
Durchaus okay
Last edited: 18.01.2023 09:22

da_hooliii
Member

****
Nicht sein bestes Lied aber noch ok.